Same-load backup check Model 2026.11 · Reviewed 2026-11-04

Whole House Generator vs Battery Backup

Pick the circuits you need, say how many hours a day each runs and how long the outage lasts. See what a standby generator and a named home battery would each need to cover exactly that—kWh, kW, starting power and dated cost references.

No winner is declared, recharge is counted as zero, and neither price is a quote.

  • Same loads, same hours
  • Four named batteries
  • Covered / not covered / not enough information

01 Same-load comparison

Hold the loads and outage constant, then check both paths.

Choose the circuits you need during an outage and how many hours a day each one runs. Heating, cooling, pumps and other site-specific loads have no default—enter your own hours or the result says so.

Nothing is saved or sent: values stay in this browser tab.

Outage loads and hours per day

Watts come from the sizing worksheet. Blank hours mean “not declared.” Refrigerator, microwave and electric range start at an EIA RECS 2020 annual average ÷ 365—not a measured outage day.

Jump to the comparison result
  • Required for energy results—no default
  • RECS default: 2.67 kWh/day (annual average)
  • Required for energy results—no default
  • Required for energy results—no default
  • No default; declare if selected
  • RECS default: 0.32 kWh/day (annual average)
  • No default; declare if selected
  • No default; declare if selected
  • No default; declare if selected
  • RECS default: 0.9 kWh/day (annual average)
  • No default; declare if selected
  • No default; declare if selected
Outage duration

Recharge during the outage is counted as zero.

Generator fuel
Starting placeholder; replace it with your bill or supplier quote.
Battery configuration
13.5 kWh AC nominal (not labeled usable) · 11.5 kW continuous · no peak kW published
Datasheet maximum: 4 units.
Energy you choose not to use during the outage. Starts at 0%.
Starts at EnergySage’s 2026 quote average, $1,159/kWh (page updated 2026-08-26). Not an itemized estimate.

Same loads, same 24-hour outage

Model 2026.11

Outage energy needs hours for 3 selected loads. Battery energy: not enough information.

Outage energy
Not enough informationDeclared loads only: 3 kWh. Missing hours: Lighting & general outlets, Internet & security, Gas furnace blower.
Loads running at once
5.15 kWEvery selected load on together
With the largest start
7.5 kWAdds the gas furnace blower start

Standby generator

10 kW tierSizing worksheet: running + largest start + 20% buffer = 9,000 W

Installed planning range · itemized
Low
$7,660
Typical
$12,160
High
$16,300
  • 10 kW standby generator$2,900–$4,800
  • Automatic transfer switch$1,200–$3,200
  • Electrical installation$2,000–$3,800
  • Natural gas connection$760–$2,000
  • Site preparation$550–$1,600
  • Permits and inspection$250–$900

U.S. average location, 30 ft fuel run, automatic transfer switch, standard site, no panel work. Location, fuel distance, switch and site can be personalized in the installed-cost calculator on the home page.

Outage fuel · 24 hours

Not enough information Declare hours for every selected load to estimate fuel.

Confirm with a professional
  • Load calculation, motor locked-rotor data and the exact model’s rating on your fuel.
  • Gas meter and pipe capacity for the full-load fuel rate.
  • Placement clearances, permits and the transfer-switch design.

Home battery

1 × Tesla Powerwall 3 · 11.5 kW output setting13.5 kWh available after a 0% reserve · zero recharge

  • Energy for the outageNot enough information
    Needed
    —
    Available
    13.5 kWh

    Declare hours per day for: Lighting & general outlets, Internet & security, Gas furnace blower.

  • Continuous outputCovered
    Needed
    5.15 kW
    Listed
    11.5 kW

    Listed continuous output meets the selected loads running at the same time.

  • Starting the largest motorNot enough information
    Needed
    7.5 kW
    Published peak
    —

    The datasheet publishes 185 A locked-rotor (LRA) load-start capability, not a peak kW with a duration. Starting coverage needs the motor's locked-rotor data and installer review.

Units neededDeclare hours for every selected load to size battery energy.

Battery price reference · one value, not itemized

$15,647

13.5 kWh listed × $1,159/kWh. Marketplace quote average, not an itemized estimate. It is not known whether a quote includes the inverter, gateway, backup panel or electrical work, permits, or solar pairing.
Confirm with a professional
  • Installer output setting, backup gateway or panel, and system-level unit limits.
  • Motor starting (locked-rotor amps) and temperature derating at your site.
  • Whether solar or a generator can recharge during a long outage; this tool assumes none.

This comparison does not pick a winner. Outage length, which loads matter, fuel availability, noise and placement, solar, incentives and budget change the choice. Neither price is a quote.

Generator vs battery backup, factor by factor.

Use the same loads and outage hours above, then compare the conditions around each system. These are planning differences and questions to verify—not a ranking of the two paths.

Standby generator and home battery: ten factors to verify for your project
FactorStandby generatorHome batteryWhat to verify
Installed cost basisItemized low / typical / high installed range for the sized generator. Outage fuel is shown separately.A dated marketplace quote average of $1,159/kWh × listed energy (updated 2026-08-26), not an itemized scope.Compare written scope, not just totals. Check the generator installed-cost guide and the price inclusions and unknowns below.
What it can runSize for simultaneous running kW and the largest motor-starting surge, not floor area alone.Check stored energy, continuous kW and starting capability separately. Added units follow the named model’s documented system limits.Check exact-model ratings, output settings and motor-start data using the sizing worksheet and battery specifications.
How long it runsFuel use depends on operating load and runtime. Continued operation needs fuel availability and the exact manual’s checks and service stops.Stored energy, per-load hours, reserve and retained capacity set the runtime basis. This comparison counts zero recharge.Use the outage fuel calculator and check service needs. Neither result guarantees uninterrupted operation.
Refuel / rechargeNatural gas needs continuing utility supply; propane needs stored fuel and delivery arrangements.Recharge needs an available, compatible source. Solar during an outage depends on the system configuration, weather and household loads.Confirm fuel-provider arrangements or the installer’s grid-down recharge plan. The named battery documents do not make solar production a guaranteed outage supply.
Scheduled maintenanceCalendar time and run hours both matter. Our professional-service planning interval is 1 year or 100 run hours, whichever comes first; the exact manual controls.No engine-oil service. Check the battery manual for inspections, monitoring and warranty conditions rather than assuming zero upkeep.Build a scheduled-maintenance budget for the generator and obtain the battery’s written service requirements.
NoiseEngine noise while running; check the model’s published sound level and local rules.Inverter and cooling-system sound are model-specific. Check the specification rather than assuming silence.Compare exact-model sound specifications and their test conditions, then check local noise requirements. No numeric sound comparison is assumed here.
Service life & warrantyService life depends on runtime, maintenance and condition. No universal generator lifespan is assumed.Tesla Powerwall 3 warranty example: 70% of 13.5 kWh at 10 years; throughput condition depends on application. A retained-capacity floor is not a predicted service life or degradation curve.Review each model’s term, cycle or throughput conditions in the battery warranty sources. The maintenance tool budgets scheduled work, not generator replacement life.
Exhaust & placementCombustion exhaust, openings, airflow and service access constrain outdoor placement.No combustion exhaust in normal use. Exact-model installation and fire/electrical requirements still apply.Use the generator placement checklist; confirm battery siting with its installer and local reviewers. No universal clearance applies here.
Incentives / taxNo incentive is deducted from this page’s installed range.The reference price is before incentives; no eligibility is assumed.Use the 2026 federal tax checker and verify project-specific rules before including an incentive in a budget.
Using both togetherIn a proposed layered plan, identify which outage loads and hours the generator would cover.Identify which loads and hours stored energy would cover. Compatibility is system-specific.The PWRcell 2 specification lists select generator integrations, not every pairing. Have installers verify controls, transfer and any charging path; this tool models separate paths only.

When each typically fits

These conditions frame a discussion with installers; none selects a winner.

  • Multi-day outages with heating or other sustained loads: a standby-generator plan may fit when fuel supply, running and starting capacity, service stops and placement can be resolved. A battery plan still needs enough stored energy or a separately verified recharge design for the same hours.
  • A noise-sensitive site, solar pairing or daily time-of-use use: a battery plan may fit when its output, reserve and supported operating modes meet those tasks. Verify sound specifications, the utility tariff and warranty conditions. This tool estimates neither daily bill savings nor solar recharge.
  • A layered backup plan: if different resources would cover different loads or outage periods, ask qualified installers for a compatible combined design. Adding the two separate tool results is not a hybrid-system calculation.

Power, energy and starting: three different questions.

A generator is sized by power—how many kilowatts can run at once, plus the brief surge when a motor starts. Once installed, it keeps producing while natural gas flows or propane lasts.

A battery must pass three checks for the same outage: enough stored energy (kWh) for every hour of the outage without recharge, enough continuous output (kW) for everything on at once, and enough peak output to start the largest motor. A system can pass one check and fail another, so each is reported separately.

  • Outage energy = Σ(running watts × hours per day ÷ 1,000) ÷ 24 × outage hours.
  • Covered means the listed figure meets the need; not covered means it falls short; not enough information means an hour value or a published peak rating is missing, so the tool will not guess.
  • Watts are worksheet planning values. Nameplate or worksheet watts can exceed a load’s real average draw, so energy is a planning bound, not metered use.

Worked example: 24-hour outage, essentials plus a furnace blower.

Refrigerator and microwave use their RECS defaults. Hours for the other loads are declared here only to illustrate the method—lighting and outlets 4 h/day, internet and security 24 h/day, gas furnace blower 8 h/day. Outage energy is 21 kWh; 5.2 kW runs at once and 7.5 kW is needed while the furnace blower starts.

One unit (or the listed PWRcell 2 configuration) of each named battery against the same example loads
BatteryListed energy / continuousEnergy, 24 hContinuousStartingUnits neededPrice reference
Tesla Powerwall 3 · 11.5 kW output setting13.5 kWh nominal / 11.5 kWNot coveredCoveredNot enough information2 units$15,647not itemized
Enphase IQ Battery 10C10 kWh usable / 7.08 kWNot coveredCoveredNot enough information3 units$11,590not itemized
Generac PWRcell 2 · M6 (6 modules)18 kWh usable / 10.5 kWNot coveredCoveredNot enough informationM6 ×2 (two cabinets, 12 modules)$20,862not itemized
FranklinWH aPower 215 kWh usable / 10 kWNot coveredCoveredCovered2 units$17,385not itemized

Generator side for the same loads: a 10 kW tier, an itemized installed planning range of $7,660–$16,300 ($12,160 typical, U.S. average, natural gas), and $30–$37 of natural gas for 24 hours at $1.50/therm. The average load is about 8.7% of the tier, below the lowest modeled fuel band, so that fuel range is an upper bound. Battery prices use $1,159/kWh × listed kWh for one unit.

What each price includes, excludes, and leaves unknown.

The two cost numbers come from different kinds of evidence. Read them side by side, not as a subtraction.

Scope of the generator installed range and the battery price reference
QuestionStandby generatorHome battery
What the number isItemized planning range from this site's model: equipment, transfer switch, electrical, fuel connection, site, permits.One dated marketplace quote average × listed kWh. Not itemized.
Known to be includedEvery line shown in the result, each with its own low / typical / high value.A complete installed battery quote as reported by the marketplace.
Not includedPanel work (off here), unusual site work, gas service upgrades, fuel during the outage (shown separately), maintenance.Incentives, solar panels, recharge during the outage, replacement over time.
UnknownYour contractor's actual scope and price—compare written quotes.Whether quotes include an inverter, gateway, backup panel, electrical work, permits, or solar pairing; no published range.

Which loads have a default—and why most do not.

Three loads start from the U.S. Energy Information Administration’s 2020 Residential Energy Consumption Survey (single-family detached homes): all refrigerators 976 kWh a year, microwaves 115 kWh and electric cooking 327 kWh, each divided by 365. They are annual averages, not measurements from an outage day.

Central air, furnace blowers, water heaters, well and sump pumps, EV charging, dryers, lighting and communications equipment have no default. Their use on an outage day depends on season, weather and household choices, so the tool asks you for hours instead of averaging them away.

Out of scope: portable generators, diesel, vehicle-to-home, off-grid systems, “solar generators,” hybrid-system design, brand rankings, continuous medical-equipment power, incentives, payback and lifecycle cost. For federal tax questions, use the 2026 generator tax-credit checker.

Evidence Dated sources

Manufacturer datasheets, EIA averages and one dated price reference.

Battery figures come from each manufacturer’s current datasheet and warranty, checked 2026-11-04. The generator side reuses this site’s sizing, installed-cost and running-cost models with their own evidence registers.

01
Tesla

Powerwall 3 Datasheet (North America)

13.5 kWh AC nominal battery energy per unit; configurable 5.8 / 7.6 / 10 / 11.5 kW continuous output; 185 A LRA load start; up to 4 Powerwall 3 units for power scalability.

File republished 2026-09-11; cited fields unchanged from the 2026-08-24 capture · checked 2026-11-04. Energy is labeled nominal, not usable, and is shown that way. Load start is published in amps (LRA), not as peak kW with a duration.

Open source
02
Tesla

Powerwall Limited Warranty (USA)

Powerwall 3 retains 70% of 13.5 kWh at 10 years; throughput condition depends on application.

Effective 2026-05-06 (file republished 2026-10-27) · checked 2026-11-04. A contractual floor, not an expected degradation curve.

Open source
03
Enphase

IQ Battery 10C Data Sheet

10.0 kWh usable capacity (includes a 2% safety limit and 3% night sustenance reserve); 7.08 kW maximum continuous discharge; 56 A for 3 s / 44.8 A for 10 s peak current and up to 90 A LRA; 60% capacity, up to 15 years or 6,000 cycles.

DSH-00565-10.0, 2026-07-22 (editorial update; cited values unchanged from 9.0) · checked 2026-11-04. Peak capability is published as current and duration, not peak kW. No system unit maximum is stated on the sheet.

Open source
04
Generac

PWRcell 2 Specification Sheet

Usable energy 9 / 12 / 15 / 18 / 36 kWh for M3 / M4 / M5 / M6 / M6×2; maximum continuous power 5.2 / 7 / 8.7 / 10.5 / 11.5 kW; AC start capacity 65–130 A under stated conditions.

A0008625505, file dated 2026-03-25 · checked 2026-11-04. Power does not scale linearly with cabinets, so only the listed configurations are offered. Start capacity is in amps, not peak kW.

Open source
05
Generac

PWRcell 2 Limited Warranty

Battery modules: 10 years or 7.56 MWh per module; at least 70% of nameplate at the end of the warranty period.

Rev B (file dated 2025-07-10) · checked 2026-11-04. A contractual floor, not an expected degradation curve; connectivity conditions apply.

Open source
06
FranklinWH

aPower 2 Datasheet

15 kWh AC usable system energy per unit; 10 kW / 11.5 kVA continuous; off-grid peak 15 kW for 10 s and 25 kW for 1 s; 185 A LRA; up to 15 units per aGate.

Datasheet dated 2026-10-09 (cited values unchanged from 2025-12-16) · checked 2026-11-04. Peak values apply under the documented off-grid conditions and the 11.5 kVA rating.

Open source
07
FranklinWH

FranklinWH System Limited Warranty for End Users

aPower 2 retains at least 70% of 15 kWh at 15 years or 60 MWh throughput, whichever comes first.

Effective 2026-10-28 · checked 2026-11-04. A contractual floor, not an expected degradation curve; connectivity conditions apply.

Open source
08
U.S. Energy Information Administration

RECS 2020 Table CE5.3b — household site electricity end-use consumption (kWh)

Single-family detached annual kWh per household using the end use: all refrigerators 976, microwaves 115, cooking 327.

Released 2023-06; revised 2024-03 · checked 2026-11-01. Annual averages. Valid only as non-seasonal daily defaults (÷ 365); not an outage-day measurement and never used for heating or cooling.

Open source
09
EnergySage

Your Guide to Home Batteries in 2026

Marketplace battery quote average of $1,159/kWh; 13.5 kWh ≈ $15,647 installed before incentives.

Page updated 2026-08-26 · checked 2026-11-04. A quote average, not transactions and not an itemized estimate. No national range, and the scope (inverter, gateway, backup panel, electrical work, permits, solar pairing) is not stated.

Open source
Review all 7 comparison assumption groupsCurrent values, evidence boundaries, references and review dates
Generator-vs-battery assumptions, values, evidence boundaries and review version
Model fieldCurrent value or ruleEvidence boundaryReference and review
Outage energy from watts and hoursΣ(running watts × hours per day ÷ 1,000) ÷ 24 × outage hours.Internal planning assumptionA unit identity (1 kWh = 1,000 W for 1 hour) applied to declared running watts and hours. Nameplate or worksheet watts can exceed actual average draw, so the result is a planning bound, not metered use.Internal planning ruleReviewed 2026-11-04 · Model 2026.11
Non-seasonal hours-per-day defaultsRefrigerator 976, microwave 115, electric range/oven 327 kWh/year ÷ 365, converted to hours at the worksheet running watts. Every other load has no default.External referenceAnnual averages, not outage-day measurements. Cooling, heating, water heating, pumps, EV charging, lighting, and communications loads must be declared by the visitor; otherwise the result shows not enough information.U.S. Energy Information Administration: RECS 2020 Table CE5.3b — household site electricity end-use consumption (kWh) ↗Reviewed 2026-11-04 · Model 2026.11
Battery energy, continuous and peak outputPowerwall 3 13.5 kWh AC nominal / 11.5 kW; IQ Battery 10C 10.0 kWh usable / 7.08 kW; PWRcell 2 M3–M6×2 9–36 kWh usable / 5.2–11.5 kW; aPower 2 15 kWh AC usable / 10 kW, 15 kW for 10 s peak.External referenceBeginning-of-life datasheet values. Round-trip efficiency is not applied again; nominal energy is labeled instead of converted; peak is compared only where a peak kW and duration are published. Installer configuration, temperature derating, and system limits control the real result.Tesla: Powerwall 3 Datasheet (North America) ↗Enphase: IQ Battery 10C Data Sheet ↗Generac: PWRcell 2 Specification Sheet ↗FranklinWH: aPower 2 Datasheet ↗Reviewed 2026-11-04 · Model 2026.11
Warranty-floor sensitivityOptional: Powerwall 3 70%, IQ Battery 10C 60%, PWRcell 2 70%, aPower 2 70% of listed energy.External referenceA contractual minimum at the end of the warranty term, not expected degradation. Off by default.Tesla: Powerwall Limited Warranty (USA) ↗Enphase: IQ Battery 10C Data Sheet ↗Generac: PWRcell 2 Limited Warranty ↗FranklinWH: FranklinWH System Limited Warranty for End Users ↗Reviewed 2026-11-04 · Model 2026.11
Battery price referenceEditable; starts at $1,159/kWh (page updated 2026-08-26). Reference = units × listed kWh × $/kWh, one value, no range.External referenceA one-time, page-specific exception to the itemized low / typical / high rule. Scope inclusions are unknown, so the value is not comparable line-for-line with the generator's itemized range.EnergySage: Your Guide to Home Batteries in 2026 ↗Reviewed 2026-11-04 · Model 2026.11
Generator tier, installed range and fuelSizing worksheet with its 20% buffer → kW tier; installed-cost model at that tier (U.S. average, 30 ft fuel run, automatic switch, standard site, no panel work); running-cost curve at the band containing the average outage load.Reused site modelEach reused model keeps its own evidence register and review date. Fuel is shown only for the 10, 14, 18, 22 and 26 kW curves; below a 25% average load the lightest band is an upper planning bound.This site’s existing modelsReviewed 2026-11-04 · Model 2026.11
Three-state coverage and units neededEach check is covered, not covered, or not enough information. Battery recharge during the outage is zero. Units needed = the largest of energy, continuous, and (when published) peak requirements.Internal planning assumptionCoverage is a planning screen, not a design. It never names a winner, a recommendation, a payback period, or a lifecycle cost.Internal planning ruleReviewed 2026-11-04 · Model 2026.11

Review owner: Generator Budget project maintainer. Reviewed 2026-11-04. Rechecked quarterly and whenever a listed datasheet or warranty, the EnergySage average, or the EIA survey changes. Send a correction or source update.

FAQ Plain-language answers

Generator vs battery backup questions.

These answers use the same rules and sources as the comparison tool.

01Which is better, a whole house generator or a battery backup?

Neither is better for every home, and this page does not pick a winner. A standby generator keeps running while its fuel supply lasts, while a battery without recharge stops when its stored energy is used. The loads you must keep on, how long outages last where you live, fuel availability, noise and placement rules, solar, incentives and budget decide the choice. Use the tool to see what each path needs for the same loads and duration, then confirm the design with qualified installers.

02Why not just compare generator kW with battery kWh?

They measure different things. Kilowatts (kW) are power: how much can run at the same moment. Kilowatt-hours (kWh) are energy: power multiplied by time. A generator is sized by kW and keeps producing while fuel lasts; a battery must have enough kW for the loads and enough kWh for the whole outage. The tool therefore checks battery energy, continuous output and starting output separately.

03Why must I enter hours for air conditioning and heating myself?

Government survey data report annual averages. Spreading a year of cooling or heating evenly across 365 days badly understates a summer or winter outage day, so the tool gives those loads no default. Only refrigerator, microwave and electric-range cooking start from EIA RECS 2020 annual averages ÷ 365, labeled as averages rather than measured outage use. Until every selected load has hours, the energy result says not enough information.

04Why is the battery price a single reference value instead of a range?

No reviewed public source gives an itemized 2026 U.S. home-battery installed range with a stated scope. The tool starts at EnergySage's marketplace quote average of $1,159/kWh (page updated 2026-08-26), multiplies it by listed energy and lets you edit it. It is not known whether those quotes include an inverter, gateway, backup panel, electrical work, permits or solar pairing, so it is not comparable line-for-line with the generator's itemized range.

05Does the battery result subtract round-trip efficiency?

No. The tool uses the manufacturer's AC energy figure, which is already what the battery delivers to the home, so applying round-trip efficiency again would double-count losses. Where a datasheet labels energy as nominal rather than usable, as Tesla does for Powerwall 3, the tool shows that label instead of converting the number.

06How many Powerwalls would I need to run my house during an outage?

It depends on the loads, their daily hours and the outage length. Powerwall 3 lists 13.5 kWh AC nominal energy and up to 11.5 kW continuous output per unit, and its datasheet supports up to 4 Powerwall 3 units. Enter your loads and hours and the tool reports how many units cover energy and continuous output under zero recharge; starting large motors still needs installer review because the datasheet publishes locked-rotor amps, not peak kW.

07Can solar panels recharge the battery during the outage?

Sometimes, but not in this tool. Solar recharge depends on the inverter configuration, season, weather and how much the home uses during the day, so the comparison counts recharge as zero. That is a conservative planning boundary, not a prediction. Ask the installer how the specific system behaves when the grid is down.

08Can I use a standby generator and a home battery together?

Some systems support specific combinations, but compatibility is not universal. The reviewed PWRcell 2 specification, for example, lists integration with select Generac standby generators. Ask qualified installers to confirm the exact equipment, controls, transfer arrangement and any charging path. This tool compares two separate backup paths; it does not size or simulate a combined system.